Discussion Paper · March 2026, presented at the PPGE/IE-UFRJ Research Seminar on 18 June; 2nd version, October 2026
Four tests for a valuation report
«Epistemic audit of asset valuation: four tests on terminal value and three strategies for estimating the epistemic surplus ratio»
What it shows. Turns the thesis's diagnosis into a procedure for any valuation report, in four tests: anchoring (what fraction of value rests on cash flows projected one by one), aggregation (whether the perpetuity fits the growth of the system), decomposition (operating value or tax transfer) and convention (what must be declared rather than estimated). The second version adds two examinations of the observational base (independence and availability) and a rule of minimal sufficient intervention, which ranks remedies by cost and by the risk of aggravating the problem. The components have distinct standing: some follow from the definitions, others are tests still to be validated on a sample, others are institutional recommendations. Applied to seven configurations of contemporary Brazilian capitalism and, finally, to itself.
For the board. Before deciding on the basis of a valuation, four questions: how much of the value is anchored, whether the perpetuity fits the sector, how much is tax, and what is declared convention.