Skip to content
Miguel Couto Ramos

research

A Discussion Paper and nine articles on what, in a valuation opinion, is estimate and what is convention, and what follows for those who decide.

Research

one question, ten pieces of work

Post-doctoral fellowship at the UFRJ Institute of Economics (February to July 2026), supervised by Franklin Serrano: a Discussion Paper and eight articles during the fellowship, and the synthesis article in August. Reading order: the Discussion Paper, which is the operational piece; the four domains, where the six modes of failure are built; the extensions and the general theory that closes the set.

The instrument · March 2026, revised in October

Discussion Paper · March 2026, presented at the PPGE/IE-UFRJ Research Seminar on 18 June; 2nd version, October 2026

Four tests for a valuation report

«Epistemic audit of asset valuation: four tests on terminal value and three strategies for estimating the epistemic surplus ratio»

What it shows. Turns the thesis's diagnosis into a procedure for any valuation report, in four tests: anchoring (what fraction of value rests on cash flows projected one by one), aggregation (whether the perpetuity fits the growth of the system), decomposition (operating value or tax transfer) and convention (what must be declared rather than estimated). The second version adds two examinations of the observational base (independence and availability) and a rule of minimal sufficient intervention, which ranks remedies by cost and by the risk of aggravating the problem. The components have distinct standing: some follow from the definitions, others are tests still to be validated on a sample, others are institutional recommendations. Applied to seven configurations of contemporary Brazilian capitalism and, finally, to itself.

For the board. Before deciding on the basis of a valuation, four questions: how much of the value is anchored, whether the perpetuity fits the sector, how much is tax, and what is declared convention.

Read the PDF (in Portuguese)

Four domains · February and March 2026

Article · February 2026

Terminal value

«Terminal value as a problem of empirical meaning: Constitutive Pragmatic Epistemology applied to discounted cash flow valuation and the APV framework»

What it shows. The component that, in many discounted cash flow valuations, accounts for most of the value, in a proportion that depends on the horizon, the cash flows, the rate and growth, is neither verifiable, falsifiable, translatable nor confirmable, and the transaction price does not test it, because it results from the valuation itself. Proposes an empirical anchoring index and shows that only adjusted present value separates surplus produced from tax transfer.

For the board. In the opinion, terminal value is shown separately, with its parameters declared as conventions: the board knows how much of the number is convention.

Read the PDF (in Portuguese)

Article · February 2026

Expectations

«Expectations as dispositional terms: empirical meaning, convention and distributive conflict in inflation- and growth-targeting regimes»

What it shows. Expectations are introduced at once by surveys and by markets, and the risk premium that reconciles the two is circular. Surveys are reputational tournaments: measured anchoring cannot tell firm belief from conformity to the focal point, and publishing them produces the coordination they claim to measure.

For the board. Macroeconomic assumptions enter the opinion with the source and mechanism that produced them (survey, market or target) because they do not measure the same thing.

Read the PDF (in Portuguese)

Article · March 2026

The unverifiable hierarchy

«The unverifiable hierarchy: empirical meaning, epistemic order and rule design in the negotiation of shareholder disputes»

What it shows. The epistemic order of a rule is the depth of the hierarchy of beliefs on which its incentive depends: the higher it is, the less verifiable, and null at infinite order. Hence a criterion of parsimony in rule design, and a sixth mode of failure: mandatory, confidential arbitration, which suppresses the observational base by institutional arrangement.

For the board. In an exit clause or an agreement between branches of a family, the board should prefer the mechanism that can be verified without reading intentions.

Read the PDF (in Portuguese)

Article · March 2026

The impossible comparable

«The impossible comparable: empirical meaning, band of discretion and the compossibility of failure modes in real-estate valuation»

What it shows. No two transactions differ in location alone, and the convergence of the income and comparison methods corroborates nothing. With the fifteen per cent band of discretion in the Brazilian NBR 14653 standard, the individual appraisal is unfalsifiable. It is the first domain in which all six modes of failure coexist, and their remedies do not substitute for one another.

For the board. In real estate, the decision rests on the contracted fraction of value; the rest is market convention and should be treated as such.

Read the PDF (in Portuguese)

Extensions · March to June 2026

Article · March 2026

Three magnitudes and a single number

«Three magnitudes and a single number: perceived value, value and price in the valuation of businesses, financial assets and real estate»

What it shows. Perceived value is a disposition revealed only in the offer; value is relative to a declared basis; price is an observation, but not an observation of either of the other two. A price close to the appraisal is explained by a focal point and by the appraisal adjusting to the price, and does not prove the appraisal was right.

For the board. A valuation opinion says whether the price falls within the value range on a declared basis, and not that the price is the value.

Read the PDF (in Portuguese)

Article · March 2026

The cordial man

«Perception of the cordial man and economic dynamics from an epistemological perspective»

What it shows. Read as a trait of national character, Sérgio Buarque de Holanda’s concept instantiates all six modes of failure; reconstructed as a convention (a coordination equilibrium between a personal and an impersonal channel of exchange) it yields testable propositions. The relationship shifts the zone of agreement, with an indeterminate sign.

For the board. In related-party transactions, the board should ask for the basis of value, not a standard adjustment: the relationship has no known sign.

Read the PDF (in Portuguese)

Article · April 2026

Epistemic surplus and bargaining

«Epistemic surplus and bargaining under informational asymmetry: Constitutive Pragmatic Epistemology applied to mergers, acquisitions and corporate restructuring»

What it shows. An acquisition premium mixes four magnitudes (structural surplus, tax transfer, appropriation and dissipation), and prices provide only two equations: a zero return for the acquirer is compatible with an inert transaction, with a productive one appropriated by the target or with dissipated surplus. Surplus is determined by structure; its division, by disagreement points, impatience, commitment capacity and private information. Due diligence produces epistemic surplus and the competitive process divides it; an exclusivity or a break fee only redistributes if it does not exclude a more productive combination.

For the board. The board separates two questions (does the transaction create value? who keeps it?) and does not accept an answer to the second that runs through the first.

Read the PDF (in Portuguese)

Article · June 2026

The solubility of finance

«The solubility of finance: the perpetual growth rate as a term of a vacuously satisfied reduction sentence»

What it shows. The perpetual growth rate has the structure of the classic solubility example (the object never immersed in water), yet it determines most of the value of an asset valued by discounted cash flows. Distinguishes three modes of vacuity (factual, nomological and epistemic), identifies a mechanism absent from the classic examples, institutional substitution (trading and revaluing the asset before the horizon prevents the test condition from occurring), and reclassifies the rate as a parameter of the economic system and a constitutive principle, and not as a disposition of the asset.

For the board. The perpetuity rate is the costliest choice in a valuation report: the board should see it set before the result, not adjusted to it.

Read the PDF (in Portuguese)

Synthesis · August 2026

Synthesis article · August 2026

The general theory of failure modes

«The institutional aetiology of empirical insignificance: a general theory of the failure modes of empirical meaning and of the non-substitutability of remedies»

What it shows. Closes the set. Under an explicit decomposition hypothesis, the six modes of failure identified across eight domains derive from the five places at which the introduction of a term can fail; the completeness of the taxonomy is relative to that form of introduction and to that hypothesis. What fails is not the word but the relation between the term, the practice, the base and the ontology. Proves the non-substitutability of remedies and its exception, epistemic iatrogenesis: publishing the suppressed base, once it feeds the practice itself, turns the sixth mode into the third.

For the board. Before accepting a correction, the board asks which mode of failure it addresses: the remedy for one mode does not correct the others, and transparency can even create a new one.

Read the PDF (in Portuguese)

All work written in Brazilian Portuguese; definitive versions dated 30 October 2026. The nine articles were submitted to peer-reviewed journals at the end of October 2026.

The cross-cutting result

the six modes of failure

Six ways in which an economic term stops saying anything about the world. Each mode has its own remedy, which does not cure the others.

I Unrealisable test condition What failsThe term requires an observation that can never occur; the sentence is vacuously satisfied. Where it appearsTerminal value, potential output, the natural rate; the locational coefficient of a property. RemedyIt cannot be removed, only made visible: report the anchoring index.
II Non-existent referent What failsThe test can be carried out, but what the term designates does not exist under the adopted ontology. Where it appearsRational expectations in a non-ergodic world; the “highest and best use” of a special-purpose property. RemedyReplace the term: for instance, the reported expectation read as a message.
III Performative observational base What failsThe observation that would test the term is produced by the practice that uses it. Where it appearsThe price the appraisal helped to form; the expectation measured by the survey that elicits it. RemedyBuild an independent observational base.
IV Incompatible reduction chains What failsThe term is introduced by two tests that give different answers. Where it appearsInflation expectations by survey and by market; willingness to pay and to accept. RemedySplit the term in two and give up reconciling them by averaging.
V Circular corrective term What failsThe term that reconciles two chains is defined by the discrepancy it should explain. Where it appearsThe inflation risk premium; an illiquidity premium measured against a rate that is not observed. RemedyGive the corrective term a test condition of its own.
VI Institutionally suppressed base What failsThe observation would be possible, but an institutional arrangement prevents it. Where it appearsMandatory, confidential shareholder arbitration; the disclosure perimeter that closes on acquisition. RemedyLift the barrier: for instance, publish anonymized awards.

All six coexist in the market value of a property. The lack of empirical meaning has, in part, a determinable institutional origin, and therefore admits institutional remedies. But transparency, which cures the sixth mode, does not reach the first or the second.

The pilot application

valuation reports and reorganization plans

The Discussion Paper’s protocol was applied, as a pilot, to valuation reports and, beyond them, to approved judicial reorganization plans.

Direction confirmed

Aggregation

The perpetual growth rates extracted from the reports that disclose them are enough to form a sample. Each one, alone, would be defensible; the weighted average exceeds the growth the system allows. The set is impossible.

Order of magnitude confirmed

Anchoring

The share of value resting on confrontable cash flows is well below half, and the horizon far exceeds what the reports themselves project. A typical report devotes dozens of pages to the explicit period and a paragraph to the terminal parameters: the inverse of the distribution of value.

Immediate recommendation

Judicial reorganization

The viability report compares a poorly anchored going concern with a heavily anchored liquidation, and the asymmetry favours the going concern. Correction: require the anchoring index of both values. And a plan can pass the distributive test in every class and merely postpone insolvency.

Refined, not yet run

The peripheral wedge

In cross-border acquisitions, the premium differential should be concentrated in the terminal share of value. The test now uses the reports available at the transaction date, before the information disappears.

The pilot sample is enough to show that the tests can be carried out and which way they point, but not to measure: the magnitude depends on how the sector is delimited, on the weighting and on what counts as autonomous spending. Next step: quantify it and extend the anchoring index to real-estate fund valuations.

Synthesis

what remains for the board

Six questions that follow from this work and apply to any valuation report, plan or proposal.

01

How much of the value is anchored?

Ask for the anchoring index: the fraction of value in cash flows projected one by one. In judicial reorganization, for both the going concern and the liquidation.

02

What is convention?

Discount rate, perpetuity and exit multiple declared as adopted conventions, and set before the result is known.

03

How much is tax?

Rebuild in adjusted present value and separate the value the transaction produces from the tax transfer of debt, goodwill and interest on equity.

04

Does it create value or only divide it?

They are distinct questions: whether the transaction produces surplus, and who appropriates it. The answer to the second does not answer the first.

05

Does the price prove the value?

No. The closeness of price and appraisal is explained by a focal point and by accommodation. An opinion says whether the price falls within the range, not that it is the value.

06

Can the rule be verified?

In shareholder agreements and exit clauses, prefer mechanisms of low epistemic order, which can be verified without guessing intentions.

None of this appears in an opinion as theory. It appears in the form: separating estimate from convention, declaring the basis and writing before knowing the result one defends.

Talks

where it was presented

30 April 2026 PPGE/IE-UFRJ Research Seminar: invited discussant.
18 June 2026 PPGE/IE-UFRJ Research Seminar: presentation of the Discussion Paper.
June 2026 Brazilian Political Economy Society (SBEP) national meeting: “O valor terminal como problema de significado empírico”.
16 July 2026 Three-hour seminar on the epistemology of business valuation for master’s and doctoral students at PPGE/IE-UFRJ.

The academic background and the root of these questions are in Education.

Contents